Skip to main content

in reply to Cory Doctorow

Didn't know about this new 'EuroPA' system, seems it comes at the perfect time.
This entry was edited (2 days ago)
in reply to Cory Doctorow

The Wero system is a rebrand of the existing Dutch iDeal system.
iDeal was created by a consortium of the Dutch banks under pressure from online retailers (ca. 2005). iDeal accounts for the vast majority of all online sales in NL.
Ever since my father had a restaurant I've hated credit-cards. For a small business, they skimmed 4 to 7% of sales and had all kinds of stupid demands (must display/advertise for the card, cannot demand a surplus for paying with CC...)

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IDEAL

Filing Wero next to bankcard payments everywhere, no roaming fees for mobile, no border checks, etc. in Europe

in reply to schnedan

@schnedan
Depends on your bank. There are no iDeal or Wero apps. Online shop make you select your bank from a list. Whatever the bank's way of authorizing the payment is works.
Banks requiring an App (and a smartphone) is an issue, but a separate one.
in reply to *sigh*Ber nard

@brnrd @schnedan Can confirm. I can handle small payments (with a self-imposed limit) from my Dutch bank (ASN) via the web browser on my PC.
in reply to *sigh*Ber nard

@brnrd I was going to mention the same thing. Credit card use in the Netherlands is AFAIK far less than US or UK because debit cards and online payments just work. I was appalled when I moved to the UK to discover people were pushed onto credit cards as the only way to build up a credit rating (another perverse system outcome).
in reply to The Casual Critic

@thecasualcritic Credit Cards are theft (especially) small business.
The Credit-Card transaction fees are a cost to all of society. They stack the odds towards large companies (that can negotiate the fee way down).
in reply to *sigh*Ber nard

@brnrd @thecasualcritic Not only that, but the bank I'm with has partnered with a "security" company that about once a year flags my card for suspicious purchases I myself made.

They blocked my card when I ate at a restaurant a few days ago. I called them to resolve it, which meant proving to them that I was who I said I was by identifying which grocery store I went to two days before.

When I complained that they did this kind of often, the lady countered with, "It wouldn't happen if you didn't buy things on strange websites!" GRRAGRGH!

1. Where I buy things is my business and mine alone!

2. The "strange website" was Drive-Thru RPG!

in reply to The Casual Critic

@thecasualcritic @brnrd online payments in the UK *do* "just work"; UK has had "Faster Payments" for nearly 20 years and most of my transfers go through in a few seconds. However eurozone's SEPA is good too these days
in reply to will-h

@flangey @brnrd
That's true, but the difference is that if I want to pay a vendor in the UK, my options are (credit) card, PayPal or Google Pay. In the Netherlands, iDeal allows me to pay by directly debiting my current account.

I mean, I have some subscriptions that I pay via credit card because they don't even offer Direct Debit.

in reply to The Casual Critic

@thecasualcritic @flangey @brnrd It's the same thing in Denmark. Since 1984 we have had the Dankort, which is a cheap debit card for payment. Now stores are pushing people to use that over visa and MasterCard because it's much cheaper for them to use.

We also have mobile pay now, which I again believe is cheaper due to the lack of requirement for a physical terminal. All you need is a sticker with your QR code.

in reply to Mark Gjøl

@Gjoel @thecasualcritic @flangey @brnrd In Poland, we have so called "Blik". All I have to do is to enter 6 digit code on the payment terminal, webpage or ATM, review transaction details in banking app and accept the payment. I can also send money to another person just by entering his phone number. There are some security considerations (with human being the weakest factor), but it works flawlessly.
in reply to Zelgaav

@zelgaav @Gjoel @thecasualcritic @flangey @brnrd same in Australia - "osko" payments are made instantly to mobile, email or bank account number, and the first two display the account name to ensure that you are paying the right party, and the third one usually (but not always) does, too. Payment extensions - not widely used - allow structured data to be exchanged (e.g. invoice or receipt to be attached to the payment).
in reply to Mark Gjøl

@Gjoel @thecasualcritic @flangey @brnrd Sweden has had Swish since 2012. It's mobile payments so easy and cheap that my 87 year old mom can use it.
in reply to Lars Hansson

@romabysen @Gjoel @thecasualcritic @flangey @brnrd The main issue is the universality of credit cards. When I walk into a store in another country as a Pole—whether physically or online—credit cards work 99.9% of the time.

I don’t have to worry about whether it’s a Polish store requiring an activated (and bank-supported) BLIK, a Swedish one where I’d need Swish, or a Dutch one using iDEAL, and so on. I would need dozens of apps or bank accounts dedicated to different payment systems, whereas credit cards... they just work.

It doesn't matter if the store is based in Poland, the UK, Sweden, Switzerland, or Germany.

I believe this is the biggest obstacle preventing alternative payment methods from breaking through national borders.

At the same time, it’s why stores in every country almost always support credit cards alongside their 'local' payment variants. Until this changes, I don’t see an easy way to replace credit cards on a universal scale.

This entry was edited (1 day ago)
in reply to Mark Gjøl

@thecasualcritic @flangey @brnrd @Gjoel Same here in Switzerland, we're using Twint since 2014 and you can pay almost anywhere with it, no terminal needed. When I buy something 2nd hand directly from the seller, I just pay him directly in seconds on the spot when I pick up the item.
in reply to Georg Ruß

@datacyclist @thecasualcritic @flangey @brnrd @Gjoel

I guess the Austrian version is #Bluecode (bluecode.com/en - now with headquarters in Switzerland) - but having a different payment system for each European country won't cut it. To be fair, there seem to be efforts to make Twint and Bluecode compatible.

This entry was edited (2 days ago)
in reply to *sigh*Ber nard

@brnrd the "can't charge a payment surcharge" is actually these days EU regulation (PSD2)

the "interchange fee cap" has been in place for a decade. Most bars and restaurants should be paying under a percent ...today at least in UK it's cheaper to take consumer credit cards then pay cash in the bank.

I think that more competion is good but bad data doesnt help

in reply to will-h

@flangey @brnrd the "interchange fee" is less than a percent, but the point of sale (POS) terminal operator charges another 1-2% on top of that.
in reply to Cory Doctorow

"and against a Brazilian judge for finding against the criminal dictator Jair Bolsonaro"

Not just a Brazilian "judge", but the Brazilian equivalent (Ministro do STF) of a SUPREME COURT JUSTICE

Cory Doctorow reshared this.

in reply to Cory Doctorow

German Commerz Bank just announced it'll be joining Wero too...
www.commerzbank.de
heise.de/news/Commerzbank-schl…
in reply to Cory Doctorow

not seen it mentioned before: in Belgium there’s Payconiq (now being rebranded as Bancontact GO); nearly free for me as a small business owner, very easy for customers as it works with a QR code and is supported by every banking app plus a bank-independent Bancontact app.

Cory Doctorow reshared this.

in reply to Cory Doctorow

This is excellent news.

Although for me personally paying with credit cards is not the killer feature but to use it as a collateral (not sure its the right word - sorry non-native here). I mean reserving hotels, renting bikes or cars, charging EVs, all require attaching credit card to an account of sorts for *future* payments. I am not aware of any european solution for this use case.