Skip to main content


PSA: social.zvavybir.eu defederates mastodon.social

Sensitive content

in reply to MadeInDex

Many people (including me) on the fediverse keep complaining that mastodon.social has too many users (> 200000), which contradicts the defederated nature of the fediverse (some of the problems of that is that it hinders in moderation and that the admins of mastodon.social have a lot of power given their position of the admin of 200000 people).
in reply to zvavybir :palestina:πŸ‰ :Green:

It feels to me like the power is already in their hands. #Mastodon gGmbH maintains the #GitHub project and joinmastodon.org.

Have you & the others who believe this tried to raise the issue with them?

A simple solution to increase signup on other #servers would be to remove the "Join mastodon.social" button on the officialΒΉ #website and instead display a full list of servers.

ΒΉ en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mastodon…

MadeInDex reshared this.

in reply to MadeInDex

This problem is well-known and raised often, but sadly no action by Eugen/the Mastodon gGmbH has been taken so far. While you are of course correct that being the official maintainers of a major software and the owners of the primary sign-up site is a lot of power, there is also a lot of power being an admin of a big instance, independent from the other things. The most pressing concern to me is that the large size means that I can't really defederate mastodon.social (I now have decided to do it anyway as the pains have become too high and I remembered ways to circumvent the worst of it (I can still subscribe to the RSS feed of the accounts I want to follow in my RSS reader and I have an old account that I can use to write to mastodon.social users if I need to)) without loosing a lot of people I care about (and losing people who want to hear from me – the list of accounts in the first post are all following me from mastodon.social), so one of the most important and potent moderation tools is effectively toothless for this one instance.
in reply to zvavybir :palestina:πŸ‰ :Green:

You raise an important issue with the #decentral / #federation idea of the #fediverse.

The concentration of power might become an increasing issue looking into the future. If, e.g., #Mastodon gGmbH decided to threaten blocking #instances unless they remove certain users, content...

Thinking about switching there are concerns of losing: SEO-wise, reach, contacts/followers, character & poll limit (😜)...

PS
#Misskey seems to have a "fairer" signup process
misskey-hub.net/en/

reshared this

in reply to MadeInDex

Your approach & the thought of switching instances somehow remind me of moving from #Whatsapp to #Signal and eventually having to have both πŸ˜…
(as the critical mass has not seemed to be reached yet)

#Mastodon currently seems to face a more immediate, more dramatic issue, though.

The active #users & #server count are continuously dropping:
mastodon-analytics.com/

#fediverse #mastodonggmbh #mastodongmbh

This entry was edited (2 weeks ago)

MadeInDex reshared this.

in reply to MadeInDex

Your old account is immediately, fully redirected to your new one, so there is no need to have both (in fact, you even can't use mastodon.social after a migration anymore (although you can cancel the migration and then use it normally again)).
in reply to MadeInDex

The user and server drop is pretty much independent of this issue and needs to be addressed separately. (also I'm not completely convinced it's true give the data on the website, it seems pretty steady.)
in reply to zvavybir :palestina:πŸ‰ :Green:

You are right, the #data seems to be significantly different on fedidb.org/ compared to mastodon-analytics.com/

@erickhun & @dansup do you have any idea why that might be? :)

in reply to MadeInDex

The reason could be that mastodon-analystics.com potentially only looks at mastodon instances, while fedidb looks at all fediverse instances.
in reply to zvavybir :palestina:πŸ‰ :Green:

I can confirm this from all the people i followed here (and in theory still follow), espically furries

Everyone ismoving to Bluesky because their friends are most active or exclusively only there, the social network effect in full blast

Most people dont have the mental energy to deal with so many different places, so they concentrate on "the one App" which does the most thing and slowly cut off the places like our Fediverse that feels loosing be useful

in reply to Laberpferd

@Laberpferd

The Nafo & Furry communities indeed seem to be mass migrating to #Bluesky!

"...social network effect in full blast" πŸ˜‚ πŸ‘

@zvavybir

in reply to MadeInDex

But even without such direct abuses it is bad. For example I tried to block mastodon.social after they started their partnership with Facebook's Threads, but couldn't due to whom I would loose. So there is already a problem.

About your concerns: Contacts and followers will be automigrated (I did it already twice without problems) and you can first check what character and poll limit an instance has (although afaik mastodon.social is *very* unusually low, so this is not really something to worry about, even if you couldn't check it first). And about SEO: At least on DuckDuckGo your website is above your mastodon account, and even if someone where to stumble on your mastodon.social account after migration, they would see where you are now (for example my old account is under mastodon.social/@zvavybir and this immediately tells you where I am now).

And yes, Misskey is better…

in reply to zvavybir :palestina:πŸ‰ :Green:

"...but couldn't due to whom I would loose."
This is the kind of thing I meant with the WhatsApp / Signal analogy ;)

It was actually a joke about this!
(I originally wrote "...character & poll limit ( joke😜)" but had to funnily remove the "joke" part because of the character limit 🀣)

The #SEO issue is more regarding things such as domain authority & ranking.

#seo
in reply to MadeInDex

I don't understand who you would loose? This is the point of the federated nature of the Fediverse – that you can change your server and still connect with everyone.
in reply to MadeInDex

Did I misunderstand you? Is the WhatsApp/Signal analogy not something you worry about when migrating? I'm confused.
in reply to zvavybir :palestina:πŸ‰ :Green:

If you switch #instances you would lose every contact on an instance blocked on the new server, correct?

So for example, if I moved the #Madeindex project to a server that has defederated Mastodon.social, every contact from mastodon.social would be gone, right?

in reply to MadeInDex

the reason i didn't use mastodon until fairly recently is the 'server' thing which is useless to me

i don't want multiple choices

i want one place to interact

glad i found mastodon social because i won't use a zuck, musk or dorsey product

in reply to Stephie

Basically people on mastodon.social cannot interact with them as much. Something like removing yourself from a group chat.

I hope that helps ..

in reply to Benaresh

So how do I migrate? Note - I only have access via the Mastodon app on an android phone as I don't have a computer.... (Sorry to be a pain....) xx
in reply to Stephie

Well good news you dont need another account or App!

usually you go to social.zvavybir.eu to change your account adress

but this doesn't work and apparently they arent defederated anymore?

IDK i am very confused right now.

in reply to Benaresh

Aw hell.... Can *ANYONE* help & advise me how to migrate to another server?
in reply to Stephie

I wrote a #guide (to the best of my very theoretical knowledge on the topic πŸ˜‹) for you: mastodon.social/@madeindex/113…


To migrate to a new #Mastodon #instance:

1. Find a new server.

You can either use this great #tool by @TheKinrar to help you choose:
instances.social

Or the official tool (with a limited selection):
joinmastodon.org/servers

2. Create a profile on the new #server

3. Next, redirect both #profiles to each other:
.../settings/migration (Move.../Moving...)

4. You can optionally choose to export & import your data: .../settings/export

@newstephie @Benaresh

#mastodonmigration #fediverse


in reply to MadeInDex

This is all ridiculously complex & unnecessary.... πŸ˜₯πŸ˜₯πŸ˜₯πŸ˜₯πŸ˜₯πŸ˜₯πŸ˜₯
⇧