The Science is Not Settled: How Weak Evidence is Fuelling a National Push to Ban Social Media for Youth
eff.org/deeplinks/2026/05/scie…
eff.org/deeplinks/2026/05/scie…
The Science is Not Settled: How Weak Evidence is Fueling a National Push to Ban Social Media for Youth
As statehouses ramp up for 2026, we’re seeing a familiar and concerning trend of lawmakers rushing to regulate the internet based on shockingly shaky science.Electronic Frontier Foundation

MadeInDex 📰🌎
in reply to kim_harding ✅ • • •Samuel Lison
in reply to MadeInDex 📰🌎 • • •MadeInDex 📰🌎
in reply to Samuel Lison • • •MadeInDex 📰🌎 reshared this.
Mark Newton
in reply to MadeInDex 📰🌎 • • •MadeInDex 📰🌎
in reply to Mark Newton • • •Mark Newton
in reply to MadeInDex 📰🌎 • • •@madeindex @samuel I only ask because corp-run social media has been around for a generation now, and if it “certainly” harmed kids’ wellbeing we’d have a major issue now with the cohort of them who’ve become adults, and we actually don’t and that cohort seems quite normal.
And also the experts who study it academically can’t form consensus on whether it’s harmful, so it isn’t at all obvious that it is.
We can speculate about whether it’s bad for kids’ wellbeing, or we can pick a specific child and assert that it’s bad for that individual, but it isn’t at all certain that it’s bad for kids in general.
That’s all.
MadeInDex 📰🌎
in reply to Mark Newton • • •@NewtonMark
Young adults don't seem that mentally healthy to me at all.
The rates of serious mental illness (e.g. in the US) are very worrying.
Yes, I'm not an expert, but many articles I have read & my observations of the kids around me lead me to believe - corporate social media is a major factor in this.
For example, the recent social media addiction trials in the US found #Meta liable for harming teens (others settled).
techcrunch.com/2026/03/31/meta…
@samuel
Meta was finally held accountable for harming teens. Now what? | TechCrunch
Amanda Silberling (TechCrunch)MadeInDex 📰🌎 reshared this.
tuga
in reply to MadeInDex 📰🌎 • • •@madeindex
Yup... it's never the parents'.
@NewtonMark @samuel
MadeInDex 📰🌎
in reply to tuga • • •IMO A solid mix of factors traumatizes the kids these days ;) @NewtonMark @samuel
Samuel Lison
in reply to MadeInDex 📰🌎 • • •MadeInDex 📰🌎
in reply to Samuel Lison • • •@samuel I would not be against complete digital transparency if we lived in an utopian society, but as things stand, the "system" is frequently abused by the elites & corps.
Therefore if, if this were to pass now & you did anything they don't like, they will be able to stop you even easier & likely completely.
It would completely rob us of the ability to fight back.
Part 1/2
#Privacy
MadeInDex 📰🌎 reshared this.
MadeInDex 📰🌎
in reply to MadeInDex 📰🌎 • • •@samuel 2/2
E.g. posting something about a politician being corrupt or a corp evil & instantly getting sued for reputational damages, insulting an official etc.
MadeInDex 📰🌎 reshared this.
Samuel Lison
in reply to MadeInDex 📰🌎 • • •MadeInDex 📰🌎
in reply to Samuel Lison • • •Samuel Lison
in reply to MadeInDex 📰🌎 • • •MadeInDex 📰🌎
in reply to Samuel Lison • • •@samuel I do wonder how much of the total traffic those are handling (since most (in some cases I feel like all) of the exit IPs seem to already be blocked by certain websites) and how many private citizens still would do it, if it became illegal 🤷
I do hope it never comes to that either though.
MadeInDex 📰🌎
in reply to MadeInDex 📰🌎 • • •Taran Rampersad
in reply to MadeInDex 📰🌎 • • •@madeindex @samuel good comment.
That said, that they 'frequently do it' is the system. What is being negotiated is the cost of the social permission.
The line is 'way back there' for me.
MadeInDex 📰🌎
in reply to Taran Rampersad • • •@knowprose Thank you so much friend! Means a lot ❤
💯 agreed! It's sad but that is the reality we live in.
@samuel
MadeInDex 📰🌎
in reply to MadeInDex 📰🌎 • • •@knowprose
I noticed many people believe, that Western countries ranking low on corruption indexes, shows they aren't corrupt as hell.
To me this just means it's at a higher, much harder to prove level.
Instead of starting at the cop level (which is still possible with connections), it starts at the points where multi-millions can be made without anyone really noticing.
E.g. farm land > residential use, construction projects, sale of government properties, favors for corps etc.
@samuel
MadeInDex 📰🌎 reshared this.
Flash Mob Of One
in reply to MadeInDex 📰🌎 • • •@madeindex @knowprose @samuel I live in a country that pardoned literal insurrectionists.
I'm not sure there's a level of corruption that isn't actionable anymore. (Unless you're the CEO of a health insurance company.)
Ben Cox
in reply to MadeInDex 📰🌎 • • •I think Western countries rank low on corruption indexes because those indexes were designed not to include the specific types of corruption in which they generally engage.
@knowprose
MadeInDex 📰🌎
in reply to Ben Cox • • •💯 That is a very good point!
@knowprose
1a1nC
in reply to MadeInDex 📰🌎 • • •MadeInDex 📰🌎
in reply to 1a1nC • • •Hahah love it! 💯
@knowprose @samuel