Search
Items tagged with: eLife
We should all try to give post-publication or post-rejection feedback there, I think it's really useful! Journals keep judging us, it's our turn to judge them ✊
Example for some journals:
#JournalOfNeuroscience : scirev.org/reviews/journal-of-…
#eLife: scirev.org/reviews/elife/
#PLoSBiology: scirev.org/reviews/plos-biolog…
Not that it matters, but I don't think #Clarivate could even justify delisting them:
neuromatch.social/@elduvelle/1…
(Although, it is unclear whether eLife will end up doing what they want which is basically separating accepted from non-accepted papers)
But they will stop giving #eLife an impact factor though.
On the bright side*, they at least recognized that the peer-reviewed content is of good enough quality to keep being indexed by them:We have found the cohort of content considered to have been ‘validated by peer review’ passes our 24 quality criteria. Therefore, we can continue to cover eLife in the Web of Science Core Collection.
(*) if you consider that being indexed by Clarivate is a good thing 🤷
El Duvelle (@elduvelle@neuromatch.social)
So is this the deal with the new @eLife@fediscience.org system: 1- you send your preprint 2- it is reviewed (if they so choose) 3- you eventually upload a final “version of record” OR 4- you send the reviewed preprint (+reviews) to another journal fo…Neuromatch Social
@mike I was annoyed at first but then realised that web of science is in charge of giving an #ImpactFactor to journals, and so I guess it actually makes sense since the #eLife model goes against the principle of impact factor... Right?
