While I was just deleting my remaining #Bsky accounts, I noticed this
Wow.
This is not normal..
Another very good reason to dump Bluesky 
Privacy friendly my bottoms
While I was just deleting my remaining #Bsky accounts, I noticed this
Wow.
This is not normal..
Another very good reason to dump Bluesky 
Privacy friendly my bottoms
tapafon
in reply to stux⚡️ • • •Netscape Navigator
in reply to stux⚡️ • • •FallsMom 🌻
in reply to stux⚡️ • • •stux⚡️
in reply to FallsMom 🌻 • • •@FallsMom Here on Mastodon you dont have this problem 😉 also not if you follow people from Bsky
Since it's going through a bridge
stux⚡️
in reply to stux⚡️ • • •And it only gets worse the longer and more you browse..
I have no clue what is blocked here exactly but if uBlock blocks it, it often has a good reason
So if people are not using an AdBlocker they at least load all this stuff extra
This is just bs
Chris Brown
in reply to stux⚡️ • • •stux⚡️
in reply to Chris Brown • • •Alex
in reply to stux⚡️ • • •Bruno Nicoletti
in reply to stux⚡️ • • •I run PiHole at home to filter all DNS requests on my home network. It black lists a huge range of ad servers. Works a charm on a cheap raspberry pi sitting next to my router.
pi-hole.net
Pi-hole – Network-wide Ad Blocking
pi-hole.netAllan Girvan
in reply to stux⚡️ • • •stux⚡️
in reply to Allan Girvan • • •Jimmothy Baggins
in reply to stux⚡️ • • •stux⚡️
in reply to stux⚡️ • • •FYI, I understand one can run their own #Bsky services but I would like to point out that 99% of the Bsky users can not get this running for a few bucks
The #Fediverse is made up of big and smaller servers that often require a super simple install and not a complete network
Again, how is this decentralized if it's almost made impossible to setup this yourself, let alone non-tech people..
I know for a fact there are plenty of services out there that offer Fedi servers without any tech know
Jimmothy Baggins
in reply to stux⚡️ • • •not to mention if the whole
Argument it’s to hard for most people to use Mastodon because of the instances. Then any self hosting rebuttal to me goes out the window …
If most people can’t figure out how to select an instance then no way in hell can they or will they self host
stux⚡️
in reply to Jimmothy Baggins • • •@64bithero So often they end up back on Twitter but with a different name
and hat..
Matt 🔶 (LordMatt)
in reply to stux⚡️ • • •stux⚡️
in reply to Matt 🔶 (LordMatt) • • •Xoa Gray
in reply to stux⚡️ • • •staringatclouds
in reply to stux⚡️ • • •Dennis
in reply to stux⚡️ • • •In addition, Mastodon is truly decentralized. Thousands of independent servers run the whole network and talk directly to each other.
For Bluesky, on the other hand, your data can move between servers, but the main feeds and discovery still mostly depend on Bluesky's own central service.
So bluesky is trying to look federated. Mastodon IS federated.
stux⚡️
Unknown parent • • •Holger Klein
in reply to stux⚡️ • • •The Polish Dispatch
in reply to stux⚡️ • • •iam-py-test
in reply to stux⚡️ • • •It is worth noting blocked by uBlock Origin != tracker, even though that likely is the case here. You can use uBlock Origin's logger to see what is blocked.
reddit.com/r/uBlockOrigin/comm…
Based on my testing, there are two domains blocked on Bluesky; events.bsky.app and sentry.io. Both are blocked by EasyPrivacy, which is maintained by the EasyList project and is enabled by default in uBlock Origin. Some members of the EasyList team also are part of the uBlock Origin team, and it is a respected project in the content filtering community.
events.bsky.app is first party telemetry. It collects standard telemetry information; referrer, session ID, pla
... Show more...It is worth noting blocked by uBlock Origin != tracker, even though that likely is the case here. You can use uBlock Origin's logger to see what is blocked.
reddit.com/r/uBlockOrigin/comm…
Based on my testing, there are two domains blocked on Bluesky; events.bsky.app and sentry.io. Both are blocked by EasyPrivacy, which is maintained by the EasyList project and is enabled by default in uBlock Origin. Some members of the EasyList team also are part of the uBlock Origin team, and it is a respected project in the content filtering community.
events.bsky.app is first party telemetry. It collects standard telemetry information; referrer, session ID, platform (web), IP geolocation down to the state (for US), current and previous screen (i.e. the home page), and app language. Someone did report the excessive requests as a bug, but Bluesky never responded to or addressed that report, and it is possible they are not aware of it. My guess here is that since it is blocked by uBo, the code assumes the request failed and retries it, forever. I haven't bothered confirming this, but I have heard of this happening on other sites. These retries are fairly infrequent, but if you keep the tab open long enough, they build up; given the 452 blocked requests make up 47% of the requests from this tab, I would assume this tab has been open for a long time and has accumulated many requests. In any case, the large number here is greatly inflated. If I am right, the large number is an indication of poor programming, but not a privacy invasion. If someone wasn't using uBlock Origin or equivalent software, the number of requests to this domain would probably be lower.
sentry.io is "application monitoring software". The decision to block Sentry as a tracker is not uncontroversial. I support it being blocked, but there isn't any sinister going on here. Bluesky is using Sentry to know when their users encounter errors. Whether you want them to have that data is a personal choice; I personally agree with EasyList's decision to block it, but that's just my opinion.
Also, neither of these domains relate to ads (you weren't claiming that, to be clear, but I just wanted to clarify in case someone was confused), and only one of them is a third-party "tracker" (air quotes because Sentry is controversial).
Without seeing the actual network requests uBo is blocking on your device, I can't confirm you are seeing the same results I see in my tests. I have not been able to reproduce the high volume of blocked requests, though I do see requests sent when I scroll (which makes sense as it is telemetry).
TLDR; the number of blocked requests here is very deceptive. There are two main trackers; a first-party analytics service and an error tracking service. If you consider these invasive, fine. But that determination should be based on what information they are collecting, rather than the fact there are many blocked requests from them.
And, no, I'm not a Bluesky stan. Bluesky has plenty of problems, but I want to make sure people understand what uBlock Origin is showing here and what it means.
Source: I have been using and contributing to uBlock Origin since 2021, and maintain several filterlists.
App continues to attempt to ping `events.bsky.app` even if blocked by the network/etc.
coyotoid (GitHub)Nicola
in reply to stux⚡️ • • •Austin
in reply to stux⚡️ • • •