Skip to main content

in reply to anonymiss

I don't understand the question.

Are you asking if scientists can believe that Christmas exists?

Are you asking if scientists think Christmas is a good thing?

Are you asking if scientists can believe that Jesus existed?

in reply to anonymiss

I am asking what the tree has to do with the birth of Jesus?
I also wonder why the Romans take a census in the dead of winter?
in reply to anonymiss

I guess you probably know about the non-Christian origin of the Christmas tree in Europe. It was interesting to me to discover 門松 (kadomatsu) in Japan. It's part of how New Years is celebrated. 門 is gate, and 松 is pine. At New Years (お正月), Japanese decorate their gates with pine boughs.

I've heard that there is no other historical document, other than the Christian gospels, that mention that census. I suspect it may not have occurred at all.

in reply to anonymiss

Oops.

Should be

I’ve heard that there is no other historical document, other than the Christian gospels, that mentions that census. I suspect it may not have occurred at all.
in reply to anonymiss

Who among us practice the religious christmas version? We all adhere to the (non-religious) commercial christmas version with a side-excuse for family gathering. Which is fine, because then christmas become a holiday celebration that everyone can participate in if they wish, like new year celebration, no barrier for religion or culture background of people.